Comorbidity, the condition of having two or more disorders at the same time or one after the other, is a significant issue in both substance use and mental health fields. When individuals face both substance use disorders and mental health disorders simultaneously, the interaction between these issues can complicate treatment and worsen the overall course of both conditions.
Related: Overcoming Substance Use Disorders and Common Co-Occurring Mental Health Conditions
Who is Affected by Comorbidity?
The prevalence of co-occurring mental and substance use disorders is striking. Approximately 7.7 million adults are affected by both mental and substance use disorders. This coexistence does not imply that one condition causes the other; it can be challenging to determine which disorder emerged first.
- 37.9% of the 20.3 million adults with substance use disorders also have mental illnesses.
- 18.2% of the 42.1 million adults with mental illnesses also struggle with substance use disorders.
Access to Treatment
Despite the high prevalence of comorbidity, treatment access remains a challenge:
- 52.5% of individuals with co-occurring conditions received neither mental health care nor substance use treatment.
- 34.5% received only mental health care.
- 9.1% received both mental health and substance use treatment.
- 3.9% received only substance use treatment.
These statistics highlight a critical gap in care, underscoring the need for integrated treatment approaches that address both issues concurrently.
Barriers to Treatment
The reasons for not receiving appropriate care vary, reflecting a range of systemic, personal, and financial challenges:
For Mental Health Care:
- 52.2% cited affordability issues.
- 23.8% didn’t know where to seek treatment.
- 23.0% believed they could manage the issue without help.
- 13.6% feared involuntary commitment.
- 12.4% worried about social stigma.
- 11.1% thought treatment would be ineffective.
- 10.6% felt they lacked time.
- 10.1% were concerned about confidentiality.
For Substance Use Care:
- 38.4% were not ready to quit using substances.
- 35.1% lacked insurance or couldn’t afford the cost.
- 13.1% feared negative social consequences.
- 13.0% worried about job repercussions.
- 11.5% didn’t know where to find treatment.
- 9.9% had insurance, but it didn’t cover the necessary treatment.
- 9.0% couldn’t find a suitable treatment program.
These barriers highlight the complex interplay of economic, social, and personal factors that prevent individuals from accessing the help they need.
Why Does Comorbidity Occur?
Three primary pathways contribute to the comorbidity of substance use and mental health disorders
1. Common Risk Factors
Genetic Vulnerabilities
Genetic predispositions play a crucial role in the development of both mental health and substance use disorders. Research shows that certain genes may increase the risk of developing these conditions. For example, individuals with a family history of mental illness or substance use disorders are at a higher risk due to inherited genetic factors. Specific genes can affect neurotransmitter systems, such as dopamine and serotonin, which are involved in mood regulation and reward processing. These genetic vulnerabilities can create a susceptibility to both mental health issues and substance use problems.
Epigenetic Influences
Epigenetics refers to changes in gene expression that do not involve alterations to the underlying DNA sequence. Environmental factors, such as stress, trauma, and substance exposure, can influence epigenetic mechanisms, potentially altering how genes are expressed. For instance, chronic stress or exposure to drugs can lead to epigenetic modifications that impact brain function and increase the risk of both mental health disorders and substance use. These changes can affect gene expression related to stress response, emotional regulation, and addiction pathways.
Shared Brain Functions
Certain brain regions are implicated in both mental health disorders and substance use. The brain’s reward system, including areas such as the nucleus accumbens and the prefrontal cortex, is involved in regulating mood, pleasure, and decision-making. Dysregulation in these areas can contribute to conditions like depression, anxiety, and addiction. For example, abnormalities in the brain’s reward circuitry can lead to an increased vulnerability to substance use as individuals seek to alleviate negative emotions or enhance positive feelings.
Environmental Influences
Environmental factors, such as socioeconomic status, exposure to violence, and peer influences, can significantly impact the likelihood of developing both mental health disorders and substance use issues. Living in an unstable or stressful environment, experiencing poverty, or having limited access to supportive resources can increase the risk. Environmental stressors may exacerbate mental health symptoms, leading individuals to turn to substances as a coping mechanism.
Trauma and Adverse Childhood Experiences
Exposure to trauma and adverse childhood experiences (ACEs) can profoundly impact an individual’s mental health and susceptibility to substance use. ACEs, such as physical, emotional, or sexual abuse, neglect, or witnessing domestic violence, can lead to long-lasting psychological effects. Individuals with a history of trauma may develop mental health disorders like PTSD, depression, or anxiety, and may use substances as a way to cope with or escape from their traumatic experiences.
2. Mental Illness Leading to Substance Use
Individuals with mental health conditions often use substances as a form of self-medication. The temporary relief that substances can provide may seem like a viable solution to managing symptoms of mental illness, such as anxiety, depression, or insomnia. For example, someone with severe anxiety may use alcohol or benzodiazepines to calm their nerves, or someone with chronic pain and depression may turn to opioids for both physical and emotional relief.
However, this self-medication can lead to a cycle of worsening symptoms. While substances might offer short-term alleviation, they can ultimately exacerbate underlying mental health issues. For instance, alcohol and drugs can interfere with the effectiveness of prescribed mental health medications, disrupt sleep patterns, and negatively affect mood regulation. This can lead to an increase in both the severity of mental health symptoms and the risk of developing substance use disorders.
3. Substance Use Leading to Mental Illness
Substance use can alter brain function and contribute to the development of mental health disorders. The impact of substances on the brain can be profound and long-lasting, affecting areas involved in mood, cognition, and behavior. For example, the use of stimulants like cocaine or methamphetamine can lead to changes in brain areas associated with impulse control and risk-taking behavior, potentially contributing to the development of mood disorders, anxiety, or psychosis.
Chronic substance use can lead to neuroadaptations in brain circuits involved in stress and reward processing. These changes can disrupt normal brain function and increase vulnerability to mental health conditions. For example, long-term use of alcohol or drugs can impair cognitive function, contribute to emotional instability, and exacerbate symptoms of mental health disorders such as schizophrenia or bipolar disorder.
In some cases, substance use can trigger or worsen existing mental health conditions. For instance, the use of hallucinogens or other psychoactive substances may induce or intensify psychotic symptoms in individuals predisposed to schizophrenia or other psychotic disorders.
Addressing the Challenge
Understanding the complexities of comorbidity is crucial for developing effective treatment strategies. Integrated care models that simultaneously address both mental health and substance use disorders are essential. By recognizing and addressing the barriers to treatment and understanding the underlying factors contributing to comorbidity, we can work towards more effective and compassionate care solutions.
Holistic, Compassionate Treatment in Park City and Heber
Navigating the complexities of comorbidity between substance use and mental health conditions can be challenging, but effective treatment is available. At Wasatch Crest, located in the mountains of Park City and nearby Heber, we offer a welcoming and supportive environment for those struggling with substance use and underlying mental health concerns. Our mountainside residences provide a healing setting where our clients receive integrated care that addresses the root causes of addiction. By tailoring holistic treatment to each individual’s needs, we aim to foster lasting recovery and overall well-being. Reach out to begin the path to healing and transformation.
Sources:
